[RFC PATCH 1/4] powerpc/64s: Don't init FSCR_DSCR in __init_FSCR()

[Nicholas Piggin]

Excerpts from Michael Ellerman's message of May 28, 2020 12:58 am:
> __init_FSCR() was added originally in commit 2468dcf641e4 ("powerpc:
> Add support for context switching the TAR register") (Feb 2013), and
> only set FSCR_TAR.
> 
> At that point FSCR (Facility Status and Control Register) was not
> context switched, so the setting was permanent after boot.
> 
> Later we added initialisation of FSCR_DSCR to __init_FSCR(), in commit
> 54c9b2253d34 ("powerpc: Set DSCR bit in FSCR setup") (Mar 2013), again
> that was permanent after boot.
> 
> Then commit 2517617e0de6 ("powerpc: Fix context switch DSCR on
> POWER8") (Aug 2013) added a limited context switch of FSCR, just the
> FSCR_DSCR bit was context switched based on thread.dscr_inherit. That
> commit said "This clears the H/FSCR DSCR bit initially", but it
> didn't, it left the initialisation of FSCR_DSCR in __init_FSCR().
> However the initial context switch from init_task to pid 1 would clear
> FSCR_DSCR because thread.dscr_inherit was 0.
> 
> That commit also introduced the requirement that FSCR_DSCR be clear
> for user processes, so that we can take the facility unavailable
> interrupt in order to manage dscr_inherit.
> 
> Then in commit 152d523e6307 ("powerpc: Create context switch helpers
> save_sprs() and restore_sprs()") (Dec 2015) FSCR was added to
> thread_struct. However it still wasn't fully context switched, we just
> took the existing value and set FSCR_DSCR if the new thread had
> dscr_inherit set. FSCR was still initialised at boot to FSCR_DSCR |
> FSCR_TAR, but that value was not propagated into the thread_struct, so
> the initial context switch set FSCR_DSCR back to 0.
> 
> Finally commit b57bd2de8c6c ("powerpc: Improve FSCR init and context
> switching") (Jun 2016) added a full context switch of the FSCR, and
> added an initialisation of init_task.thread.fscr to FSCR_TAR |
> FSCR_EBB, but omitted FSCR_DSCR.
> 
> The end result is that swapper runs with FSCR_DSCR set because of the
> initialisation in __init_FSCR(), but no other processes do, they use
> the value from init_task.thread.fscr.
> 
> Having FSCR_DSCR set for swapper allows it to access SPR 3 from
> userspace, but swapper never runs userspace, so it has no useful
> effect. It's also confusing to have the value initialised in two
> places to two different values.
> 
> So remove FSCR_DSCR from __init_FSCR(), this at least gets us to the
> point where there's a single value of FSCR, even if it's still set in
> two places.

Thanks for sorting out this mess, everything looks good to me.

Thanks,
Nick