Meeting Minutes 2/26/2018 - RE: Redfish call

[Tanous, Ed]

FYI, the document we just looked over is posted to gerrit review here:

https://gerrit.openbmc-project.xyz/#/c/9223/

-Ed

From: Michael.E.Brown at dell.com [mailto:Michael.E.Brown at dell.com] 
Sent: Monday, February 26, 2018 3:05 PM
To: openbmc at lists.ozlabs.org; Paul.Vancil at dell.com; hramasub at in.ibm.com; Balaji.B.Rao at dell.com; bradleyb at fuzziesquirrel.com; jwcarman at us.ibm.com; pradeep.kumar36 at tcs.com; rolfb at us.ibm.com; Chris.Ong at microsoft.com; alirhas at microsoft.com; Tanous, Ed <ed.tanous at intel.com>; yupalani at microsoft.com
Cc: Krishna.Kolakaluri at deltaww.com
Subject: Meeting Minutes 2/26/2018 - RE: Redfish call

We had the inaugural meeting of the newly minted “OpenBMC Redfish Working Group” today, Feb 26, 2018. Welcome to everybody who attended, and thank you for your participation.
 
Meeting Minutes:
• Meeting Frequency: Weekly meetings. Agenda: tours of the existing redfish stacks.
• Meetings are on Mondays at 4pm CST (2PM PST)
• Action Item: Michael will send out updated meeting invite.
• Ed: Strong opinion to keep the invite on the mailing list.
• Ali: wants to run inside a(n open) “workgroup” for a while before exposing to the rest of the community. 
• Michael: strong opinion to keep invite on mailing list and keep meeting open to whoever wants to attend and contribute
• Action item: creation of workgroup for Redfish
• DONE: Michael waved his wand and we now have a “workgroup”
• Participation in the workgroup is self-selected
• Meetings are open to all who are interested
 
• Ali (Microsoft) raised the following questions to be discussed by the workgroup:
• Frequency: weekly. Monday @4pm (CST). Ali mentioned that he saw some IBM folks that had conflict for Monday. Action: Michael will send query to the mailing list regarding times and see if there is another time that can be made to work.
• Requirements:
• Schema. Microsoft has a “storage” schema implementation in their code
• What fields do we want to support?
• DMTF has standardized “Feature Profiles” which list which schema items must be supported
• OCP Profile
• OCP Base Server profile – currently open for review at DMTF
• Microsoft has seen some gaps in DMTF schema:
• Sensors: (what kind of gaps?)
• Sensor connection – pcie, thermal, fans, everything currently disaggregated. MS wants everything in one collection.
• FRU schema:
• FRU collection (Ed Tanous says that FRU collection is under review at SPMF)
• Event Logs:
• No way to uniquely identify which event it is. Everything is a string. (Message Registries might be a help here)
• Plan/Roadmap:
• Microsoft communicated that their expected date to transfer to LF of their openbmc code is first week of March. (March 5th was communicated as date)
 
• Ed Tanous (Intel) started walking through the requirements document that he has started putting together.
 
Attendees:
        Mario 
        Rolf Brutus - IBM
        Ed Tanous – Team lead for Intel
        Chris Ong – 2 boxes shipping with OpenBMC. One in production inside of Microsoft, one almost in production
        Dong Wei – ARM – wants to move from IPMI to Redfish
        Maciej – Intel DCG software team
        Yugi – Microsoft – works with Chris. Concerned with making DMTF standards out of any changes we get.
        Paul Vancil – original co-chair DMTF/redfish.
        Sachit Bakshi – Likes to talk on mute. Works on Dell storage enclosure stack
 
 
 
 
-----Original Appointment-----
From: Brown, Michael E 
Sent: Monday, February 26, 2018 3:31 PM
To: Brown, Michael E; openbmc at lists.ozlabs.org; Vancil, Paul; hramasub at in.ibm.com; Rao, Balaji B; bradleyb at fuzziesquirrel.com; jwcarman at us.ibm.com; pradeep.kumar36 at tcs.com; rolfb at us.ibm.com; Chris Ong; Ali Larijani; Tanous, Ed; Yugi Mani
Cc: Krishna Kolakaluri
Subject: Redfish call
When: Monday, February 26, 2018 4:00 PM-5:00 PM (UTC-06:00) Central Time (US & Canada).
Where: Skype Meeting
 
 
Certainly a little bit later sending out this call than I anticipated, but it sounds like everybody thought today was a good time to kick everything off.
 
Stealing Ed’s Initial agenda proposal:
 
Initial introductions
Overview of existing implementations and work
        Bmcweb implementation by Intel – Ed Tanous
        Go-redfish implementation by Dell – Michael Brown
        Redfish implementation by Microsoft – Ali Larijani/Yugi Mani/Bryan Kelly
        Paul Vancil’s open python redfish
        Others?
 
.........................................................................................................................................
→ Join Skype Meeting     
Trouble Joining? Try Skype Web App 
Join by phone
Internal:724-2663 (Global)               English (United States) 
United States, Austin: +1-512-724-2663 (Global)          English (United States) 
United States, Toll Free: +1-877-491-9738 (Global)               English (United States) 
India, Reliance:1800-30-109045 (Global)          English (United States) 
India, BSNL:1800-425-5101 (Global)               English (United States) 
Ireland, Dublin: +353-1-2794062 (Global)                 English (United Kingdom) 
England, Bracknell: +44-1344-372040 (Global)             English (United Kingdom) 
Malaysia, Penang: +60-4-6336666 (Global)                 English (United States) 
Brazil:3003-3355 (Global)                Portuguese (Brazil) 
China, Toll Free:800-858-0756 (Global)           English (United States) 
Japan, Kawasaki: +81-44-5206877 (Global)                 Japanese (Japan) 
Canada, Toronto: +1-416-7582329 (Global)                 English (United States) 
Find a local number 
 
Conference ID: 22607907
Forgot your dial-in PIN? |Help     
 
[!OC([1033])!]
.........................................................................................................................................