RCU lockup issues when CONFIG_SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR=n - any one else seeing this?

[Paul E. McKenney]

On Wed, Jul 26, 2017 at 10:50:13AM -0700, Paul E. McKenney wrote:
> On Wed, Jul 26, 2017 at 09:54:32AM -0700, David Miller wrote:
> > From: "Paul E. McKenney" <paulmck at linux.vnet.ibm.com>
> > Date: Wed, 26 Jul 2017 08:49:00 -0700
> > 
> > > On Wed, Jul 26, 2017 at 04:33:40PM +0100, Jonathan Cameron wrote:
> > >> Didn't leave it long enough. Still bad on 4.10-rc7 just took over
> > >> an hour to occur.
> > > 
> > > And it is quite possible that SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR=y and HZ_PERIODIC=y
> > > are just greatly reducing the probability of the problem rather than
> > > completely preventing it.
> > > 
> > > Still, hopefully useful information, thank you for the testing!
> > 
> > I guess that invalidates my idea to test reverting recent changes to
> > the tick-sched.c code... :-/
> > 
> > In NO_HZ_IDLE mode, what is really supposed to happen on a completely
> > idle system?
> > 
> > All the cpus enter the idle loop, have no timers programmed, and they
> > all just go to sleep until an external event happens.
> > 
> > What ensures that grace periods get processed in this regime?
> 
> There are several different situations with different mechanisms:
> 
> 1.	No grace period is in progress and no RCU callbacks are pending
> 	anywhere in the system.  In this case, some other event would
> 	need to start a grace period, so RCU just stays idle until that
> 	happens, possibly indefinitely.  According to the battery-powered
> 	embedded guys, this is a feature, not a bug.  ;-)
> 
> 2.	No grace period is in progress, but there is at least one RCU
> 	callback somewhere in the system.  In this case, the mechanism
> 	depends on CONFIG_RCU_FAST_NO_HZ:
> 
> 	CONFIG_RCU_FAST_NO_HZ=n:  The CPU on which the callback is
> 		queued will return "true" in response to the call to
> 		rcu_needs_cpu() that is made shortly before that CPU
> 		enters idle.  This will cause the scheduling-clock
> 		interrupt to remain on, despite the CPU being idle,
> 		which will in turn allow RCU's state machine to continue
> 		running out of softirq, triggered by the scheduling-clock
> 		interrupts.
> 
> 	CONFIG_RCU_FAST_NO_HZ=y:  The CPU on which the callback is queued
> 		will return "false" in response to the call to
> 		rcu_needs_cpu() that is made shortly before that CPU
> 		enters idle.  However, it will also request a next event
> 		about six seconds in the future if all callbacks do
> 		nothing but free memory (kfree_rcu()), or about four
> 		jiffies in the future if at least one callback does
> 		something more than just free memory.
> 
> 		There is also a rcu_prepare_for_idle() function that
> 		is invoked later in the idle-entry process in this case
> 		which will wake up the grace-period kthread if need be.
> 
> 3.	A grace period is in progress.  In this case the grace-period
> 	kthread is either currently running (in which case there will be
> 	at least one non-idle CPU) or is in a timed wait for its next
> 	scan for idle/offline CPUs (such CPUs need the grace-period
> 	kthread to report quiescent states on their behalf).  In this
> 	latter case, the timer subsystem will post a next event that
> 	will be the wakeup time for the grace-period kthread, or some
> 	earlier event.
> 
> 	This is where we have been seeing trouble, if for no other
> 	reason because RCU CPU stall warnings only happen when there
> 	is a grace period in progress.
> 
> That is the theory, anyway...
> 
> And when I enabled CONFIG_SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR, I still see failures.
> I did 24 half-hour rcutorture runs on the TREE01 scenario, and two of them
> saw RCU CPU stall warnings with starvation of the grace-period kthread.
> I just now started another test but without CONFIG_SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR
> to see if it makes a significance difference for my testing.  I do have
> CONFIG_RCU_FAST_NO_HZ=y in my runs.

And without CONFIG_SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR, I see five runs of 24 with RCU
CPU stall warnings.  So it seems likely that CONFIG_SOFTLOCKUP_DETECTOR
really is having an effect.

							Thanx, Paul