[PATCH v2 1/2] uprobes: Pass probed vaddr to arch_uprobe_analyze_insn()

[Oleg Nesterov]

On 06/12, Oleg Nesterov wrote:
>
> On 06/12, Srikar Dronamraju wrote:
> > >
> > > Note also that we should move this !UPROBE_COPY_INSN from
> > > install_breakpoint() to somewhere near alloc_uprobe(). This code
> > > is called only once, it looks a bit strange to use the "random" mm
> > > (the first mm vma_prio_tree_foreach() finds) and its mapping to
> > > verify the insn. In fact this is simply not correct and should be
> > > fixed, note that on x86 arch_uprobe_analyze_insn() checks
> >
> > The reason we "delay" the copy_insn to the first insert is because
> > we have to get access to mm. For archs like x86, we want to know if the
> > executable is 32 bit or not
>
> Yes. And this is wrong afaics.
>
> Once again. This !UPROBE_COPY_INSN code is called only once, and it
> uses the "random" mm. After that install_breakpoint() just calls
> set_swbp(another_mm) while the insn can be invalid because
> another_mm->ia32_compat != mm->ia32_compat.
>
> > So in effect, if we get access to
> > struct file corresponding to the inode and if the inode corresponds to
> > 32 bit executable file or 64 bit executable file during register, then
> > we can move it around alloc_uprobe().
>
> I don't think this can work. I have another simple fix in mind, I'll
> write another email later.

For example. Suppose there is some instruction in /lib64/libc.so which
is valid for 64-bit, but not for 32-bit.

Suppose that a 32-bit application does mmap("/lib64/libc.so", PROT_EXEC).

Now. If vma_prio_tree_foreach() finds this 32-bit mm first, uprobe_register()
fails even if there are other 64-bit applications which could be traced.

Or. uprobe_register() succeeds because it finds a 64-bit mm first, and
then that 32-bit application actually executes the invalid insn.

We can move arch_uprobe_analyze_insn() outside of !UPROBE_COPY_INSN block.

Or, perhaps, validate_insn_bits() should call both
validate_insn_32bits() and validate_insn_64bits(), and set the
UPROBE_VALID_IF_32 / UPROBE_VALID_IF_64 flags. install_breakpoint()
should do the additinal check before set_swbp() and verify that
.ia32_compat matches UPROBE_VALID_IF_*.

What do you think?

Oleg.