[RFC PATCH 17/17] KVM: PPC: Add an ioctl for userspace to select which platform to emulate

[Alexander Graf]

On 30.06.2011, at 18:00, Avi Kivity <avi at redhat.com> wrote:

> On 06/30/2011 06:22 PM, Alexander Graf wrote:
>>> Regarding that.  There's another option - the ioctl code embeds the structure size.  So if we extend the ioctl parsing to pad up (or truncate down) from the user's size to our size, and similarly in the other direction, we can get away from this ugliness.
>>> 
>>> Some years ago I posted a generic helper that did this (and also kmalloc'ed and kfree'd the data itself), but it wasn't received favourably.  Maybe I should try again (and we can possibly use it in kvm even if it is rejected for general use, though that's against our principles of pushing all generic infrastructure to the wider kernel).
>> 
>> 
>> That does sound interesting, but requires a lot more thought to be put into the actual code, as we basically need to read out the feature bitmap, then provide a minimum size for the chosen features and then decide if they fit in.
> 
> 
> Why? just put the things you want in the structure.
> 
> old userspace -> new kernel: we auto-zero the parts userspace left out, and zero means old behaviour, so everthing works
> new userspace -> old kernel: truncate.  Userspace shouldn't have used any new features (KVM_CAP), and we can -EINVAL if the truncated section contains a nonzero bit.

Yup, which requires knowledge in the code on what actually fits :). Logic we don't have today.


Alex