[RFC PATCH] dt-bindings: Add AST2600 i3c controller binding

[Jeremy Kerr]

Hi Krzysztof,

> You should clearly communicate that driver is coming...

OK.

> Anyway binding comes with the driver, otherwise how can we check that
> you actually implemented it?

I'll include this with the driver once we're past the RFC reviews.

> Please send patches, not RFC. RFC means you are uncertain this is even
> correct and you ask for generic discussion.

Yes, that's essentially what I'm looking for with this change -
particularly with the pullup config, which (as you say) could arguably
be a pinctrl config instead.

If we do decide to do this with pinctrl config, we'll need a separate
driver (and minimal binding) for the global register set to act as the pin
controller. That fundamentally changes the structure here - hence RFC.

> generic discussion comment - implement how other recent i3c bindings
> are implemented. This is basic device, there is nothing special here.

I'd say the global register set makes the binding layout a bit quirky,
as you've identified already.

> Since you did not respond to rest of comments, I assume you are going
> to implement them fully - including dropping the questioned
> properties.

Yep! Some of those will then be unneeded in this binding after going to a
pinctrl approach, and I'll make the fixes as you suggested.

Cheers,


Jeremy